Save the Superheroes: The Genius of a 6 Man Rotation
These days, Citi Field is looking more and more like a comic book.
Not because of the usual suspects, the hilariously bad efforts of the Mets, but because of the nicknames of their impressive pitching staff. The team is currently featuring a dynamic trio of aliases, including Thor (rookie Noah Syndergaard), the Dark Knight (ace Matt Harvey), and my personal favorite and personal creation, the Ageless Wonder (42 year-old Bartolo Colon). In order to keep their warriors fresh for each fight, the team announced this week that they will expand their Justice League Rotation to 6 arms instead of the normal 5. Many pundits have bashed this decision for days, citing the fragile mental state of pitchers and the long-term effects, but it’s not as bad as you think. In fact, the 6 man rotation could be exactly what the MLB is looking for to save pitchers from arm troubles.
Perhaps the most prominent reason that the Mets expanded their starting staff is because they simply couldn’t pick who to drop down to the minors or the bullpen. Quite frankly, that’s not a terrible problem to have. The front office called up Syndergaard from AAA Las Vegas, where he gave up only 6 earned runs in 29.2 IP, after starter Dillon Gee injured his groin. Now that Gee is back on the rehab trail, the sensitive relationship between Gee and the team is rears its ugly head again. He has explicitly told the media and the team that he prefers to be in the starting rotation over the bullpen, and would be open to being traded to fulfill his wishes. Since the market isn’t active yet and “Trade Season” hasn’t begun, it makes the most sense to bring Gee back into the rotation for the time being. Syndergaard should stay for myriad reasons, including his 2.55 ERA and his uncanny ability to draw a large crowd.
The Mets have a few pitchers that could benefit from the extra days off as well. As they have accumulated wealth in the pitching staff, they have encountered a few obstacles. Matt Harvey shout out of a cannon in 2012, striking out 11 in his first major league start en route to a 2.73 ERA in 10 starts in 2012. His whirlwind success didn’t slow to a halt until he was diagnosed with a torn ligament in his elbow in 2013, posting a 2.27 ERA and a 9-5 record up to that point. Although he crept out of the back page news, he made front page headlines by becoming one of the most visible celebrities in the country. Harvey used the same flashy demeanor when he stepped back onto a baseball field this spring, hitting 99 MPH against his first batter back from Tommy John Surgery. Only in his last two starts have we seen the rust and effects of a year and a half absence from the mound. In his most recent start against the Pirates, he gave up 6 hits and 7 earned runs in just 4 innings, the shortest outing of his career. Going to a six man rotation now is a great opportunity to rest his arm after a surprisingly strong start to this season.
Bartolo Colon is shocking himself at this point with his staggering success this year, his 18th season in the bigs. Right now, he stands at a 7-3 record, with a below-average ERA of 4.85. However, he leads the National League in walks per 9 innings pitched (0.73) and strikeouts per walk (10.8). The journeyman claims he drug free after he was suspended in 2012 for the use of testosterone and attributes his success to his well-known command his the wisdom he’s garnered from pitching for close to 20 years in the MLB (Sidenote: he also has two hits in his first 10 games, which is already tied for the third most in his career, while looking like a shaven bear with a tree trunk swinging at the plate). Getting the extra day off in between starts can do nothing but help the 42 year old Colon, who threw over 200 innings for the 8th time in his career.
There’s also the point of protecting the rookie Syndergaard during his first taste of the big leagues. The Mets don’t want to rely on him like they relied on Harvey through his first 12 months of MLB ball and like they did with Zack Wheeler. Wheeler pitched half a year of big league ball in 2013, and a full year last year, compiling almost 300 innings by the time he turns 25 on May 30th of this year. The immense workload on his young arm resulted in Tommy John Surgery before this year even started.
Perhaps a 6 man rotation could cure the arm injury epidemic that has ravaged the MLB and the minor leagues for years. Tossing in an extra day of rest could keep the entire staff, including relievers, fresh well into September and October. It would allow for extra rest to heal soreness and tightness that could turn into something much more serious. A 6 man rotation could also give minor league pitchers a chance to prove their worth earlier in their careers rather than later, providing far more exciting and promising baseball for teams, like the Mets, that have toiled in sub-mediocrity for years. There have been multiple teams just this year that have either implemented or at least thought about using the 6 man rotation. This week, the Red Sox called up highly regarded prospect Eduardo Rodriguez to pitch against the Rangers on Thursday and will go to a six man rotation for the time being. There’s also the St. Louis Cardinals, who’s ace Adam Wainwright was shut down earlier this month with a torn Achilles. For a while, the team was considering moving towards a 6 man rotation to pick up the production of Wainwright. It’s not new, and it’s not used often, but the 6 man rotation could be just what baseball needs.
I know a lot is made out of pitchers being “creatures of habit” and having their day-to-day workouts and schedules planned out like a cruise ship director’s daily planner, but if they can adapt to a strict 5 day schedule, they can just as easily re-adapt to a 6 day schedule. Pitcher’s are humans, not robots, and the adjustment to a 6 man rotation is probably easier than we think. For now though, all we can do is examine the results of the Comic-Con that the Mets pitching staff has become.